The Elderton Command Shiraz 2001 is highly evaluated by critics as a "modern classic" of the Barossa Valley, consistently receiving scores in the 95–97 point range. Experts praise it for its "high-octane" personality and its ability to maintain power and concentration without becoming overblown.
Critical Scores
- Wine Spectator (Harvey Steiman): 96 Points. Described as "built to last" with rich cherry, plum, and exotic spice flavors.
- Robert Parker (Wine Advocate): 95+ Points. Parker noted its "tremendous concentration, intensity, and power" and called it one of South Australia's great classics.
- James Halliday: 96 Points. Highlighted its fine, silky tannins and excellent overall mouthfeel.
- CellarTracker (User Average): 93.8 Points. Recent reviews from 2024 and 2025 call it "terrific" and "in a great place right now".
Tasting Profile
- Nose: Intoxicating and complex aromas of blackberries, vanilla, and chocolate, often accompanied by secondary notes of eucalyptus, espresso, and roasted game.
- Palate: Full-bodied and "seductively silky." It features deep layers of baked plum, black cherry, cocoa nibs, and sweet licorice, balanced by vibrant acidity.
- Finish: Long and lingering with notes of dark chocolate, spice, and white pepper.